Once again, tragedy along the gulf coast in general and Louisiana in particular captivate the news. Whether it was an accident caused by fate or folly of man, the explosion on the floating oil drilling platform that resulted in a massive oil spill has changed that place forever. Right wing news organizations criticize the Obama Administration for not acting more decisively at an earlier point in the time-line.
Hurricane Katrina devastated gulf coast communities from western Florida to upper Texas; Louisiana and New Orleans in particular. Left wing news organizations sustained a prolonged attack on the Bush Administration for not acting more decisively at an earlier point in the time-line.
Citizens across our nation grieve for the losses sustained by our neighbors in that region for a second time in only a few short years.
While we grieve on the one hand, criticism has been levied against the federal government for failing to act proactively in a timely manner in both of these emergencies which begs the question “Is the federal government the agency of first resort or last resort in the case of disaster?” What protocol should we employ to determine when federal assistance is needed as opposed to required?
Natural disasters such as hurricanes, tornadoes, floods and wild fires all are capable of wiping out a community or even a state. We are learning that man-made disasters can be every bit as damaging. In either case, what triggers a federal response to such a disaster? Does the federal government do joint planning with every state to determine in advance a plan of action for all perils or does the planning fall to the states?
It has become commonplace to see elected officials flying over an area devastated by a disaster in helicopters then hear that the area had been declared a “federal disaster” which triggers financial assistance during a recover, but what has to happen before the federal government’s role changes to proactively managing a disaster on the ground?
During Katrina we learned that FEMA was waiting for Louisiana to ask for assistance. Is a request for assistance part of the protocol? Should FEMA and the federal government make an assessment on their own and act unilaterally or wait to be invited?
Is there any such thing as a routine “oil rig” fire? When any oil rig explodes and burns, someone does an assessment at some level to determine the risk factors. Was that done in this case and who did follow-up? When did authorities decide this was an emergency of national significance?
Is there a process Americans can use to guide us when a disaster happens in knowing when the government will only watch and when they might mobilize and actually do something to help?
Flooding is a peril that we often see in the news and New Orleans got hit hard with Katrina, but I don’t recall the role the government played in helping all the other victims in all the other flood events that happened around the country that year or for that matter in any year.
Where are the left wing and right wing news organizations when the federal government chooses not to take an active part in a disaster? When do they decide the federal government has not acted in a timely, decisive and proactive manner?
The risk associated with living in a flood plain is periodic flooding; with living along an ocean beach is the possibility of hurricanes; with living in the mid-west is the possibility of tornadoes. Some of us live with the risk of volcanoes, earthquakes and wild fires as well. What is the federal government’s role in protecting us from those perils and saving us from them after the fact? What role should the government play in saving you if we all agree that choosing to live in a hazard zone might be perilous?
We cannot expect the federal government to swoop in to save our butts from all perils. If we live where it floods we do so at our own risk. If we opt to invest in protection from floods we need to do so at our own expense. The federal government is not responsible for paying for our own poor judgment.
We need to have federal government policies that clarify the role the federal government will play in the case of major disasters.
Press coverage should not dictate whether the government steps in or not.
Vigilance and Dedication
by Steve DanaThis election year marks the first time in recent history where mainstream Americans have actually felt the sense of urgency to change government many of us have had for many years. Loss of homes, jobs and savings will do that.
Federal bail-outs for fat cats at the expense of mainstream Americans highlight the corruptness of a system out of control. The failure of either political party to demonstrate restraint in spending has eroded confidence that they are capable of doing so. Americans have seen their government collecting and spending record levels of tax dollars with no end in sight with little consideration to the return on our investment.
“Among a people generally corrupt liberty cannot long exist.” – Edmund Burke
Failure to follow the Constitution is even more discouraging.
The fact that citizens had faith that their elected officials shared their values lulled them into a false sense of security. Inattention allowed the government to steadily erode our liberty and our property rights, but more importantly government has been undermined by questionable ethics and morality and certainly a lack of religious faith.
The idea that the government can solve all our problems has conned us into allowing government to take over our lives. The “welfare state” is on the threshold of enslaving our country.
“The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public’s money.” – Alexis de Tocqueville
Bureaucracies have mushroomed at every level of government in the name of progress. At the same time, you have to wonder what contribution those bureaucracies make to the quality of service or product delivered. What contribution does the Department of Education make to the quality of education? How does the Department of Health and Human Services improve your health? How about the Departments of Energy, Interior or Agriculture? The list goes on and on. The bureaucracies consume billions and billions of our tax dollars without actually delivering a quantifiable service to any of us. Certainly these federal agencies are guilty, but state versions are no less so.
“Americans are so enamored of equality that they would rather be equal in slavery than unequal in freedom.” – Alexis de Tocqueville
The downturn in the economy has been devastating to many, but in spite of the damage done the resultant exposure of flaws in government systems, policies and laws may turn out to be a rare opportunity to redefine government priorities both at a national and state level. We can re-establish public policy based upon Conservative values widely shared by most Americans rather than liberal progressive values that are bankrupting our country stripping away our American identity. In this case the lesson we must learn is that without vigilance and dedication to preserving our liberty on an everyday basis, our liberty is at risk.
“But what is liberty without wisdom, and without virtue? It is the greatest of all possible evils; for it is folly, vice, and madness, without tuition or restraint.” – Edmund Burke
We need to have elected officials who are proud to be Americans and are willing to fight for the Constitution of the United States.
“Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn’t pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same.” – Ronald Reagan
We have the opportunity in this election cycle to change our representatives to more accurately reflect the values of most Americans; values like smaller government and lowering the federal deficit, but more importantly values of a moral and ethical government guided by our faith in God regardless of religion.
“The greatness of America lies not in being more enlightened than any other nation, but rather in her ability to repair her faults.” – Alexis de Tocqueville
Separation of church and state does not mean elimination of faith as a driving force of our government.
“Freedom prospers when religion is vibrant and the rule of law under God is acknowledged.” – Ronald Reagan
At the end of the day, Vigilance by every citizen will be the only protection for the American way of life as visualized by the founders.
“All that’s necessary for the forces of evil to win in the world is for enough good men to do nothing.” – Edmund Burke
Posted in Partisan Politics, Political commentary, Snohomish County Political Commentary, Steve Dana Issues | Leave a Comment »