Young people today often say capitalism has failed them. They look at the cost of rent, groceries, gas, tuition, insurance, health care, and vehicles, and they conclude the system is broken. Then they look at Bill Gates, Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, Warren Buffett, Larry Ellison, and the rest of America’s billionaire class, and they decide they have found the villains.
It is an understandable reaction, but it is the wrong conclusion.
Capitalism did not make ordinary life unaffordable.
Government distorted capitalism until ordinary life became unaffordable, and then taught people to blame capitalism.
That is the point we need to recover.
Capitalism does not operate in a vacuum. It operates inside a framework created by government. Government controls the money supply. Government influences interest rates. Government taxes income, property, fuel, payroll, investment, business activity, and consumption. Government regulates housing, energy, transportation, labor, health care, education, banking, insurance, construction, and nearly every other sector of the economy.
Then private businesses are expected to function inside that framework, absorb those costs, comply with those rules, pay those taxes, survive those mandates, and still keep prices low enough that customers do not revolt.
When they cannot, capitalism gets blamed.
That is dishonest.
A restaurant owner does not set the price of a hamburger in a vacuum. He looks at beef, buns, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, fryer oil, paper goods, napkins, cleaning supplies, rent, utilities, insurance, wages, payroll taxes, workers’ compensation, credit-card fees, repairs, equipment, spoilage, licensing, bookkeeping, regulation, and debt service. He adds all those costs together, hopes customers will still walk through the door, and tries to make enough profit to survive.
If the hamburger that used to cost five dollars now costs sixteen, the lazy explanation is greed. The real explanation is cost.
And where do many of those costs come from? Inflation, regulation, labor mandates, taxes, energy policy, insurance mandates, compliance costs, permitting delays, and the steady destruction of the dollar’s purchasing power.
That is not Bill Gates’ fault. That is not Warren Buffett’s fault. That is not capitalism failing. That is government interference showing up on the menu board.
The same is true of housing. Builders did not forget how to build houses. Developers did not suddenly decide to make starter homes unaffordable. Government made land use more complicated, zoning more restrictive, permitting more expensive, environmental review more time-consuming, infrastructure fees more burdensome, and construction compliance more costly. Then people look around and wonder why young families cannot buy a house.
The answer is not capitalism. The answer is artificial scarcity created by government policy.
If government restricts where housing can be built, what kind of housing can be built, how dense it can be, how long approvals take, what fees must be paid, what materials must be used, and what conditions must be satisfied before a shovel hits the dirt, the result will be fewer homes and higher prices.
That is not a market failure. That is a government failure.
Energy is another example. Fuel is not just something we buy at the pump. Energy is embedded in everything. It is in farming, trucking, refrigeration, construction, manufacturing, shipping, warehousing, heating, cooling, and retail. Raise the cost of energy and you raise the cost of everything.
When government restricts supply, discourages investment, blocks infrastructure, mandates preferred technologies, or punishes certain fuels before alternatives are ready, the cost does not stay in the energy sector. It spreads through the entire economy.
The customer sees the price of groceries. The business owner sees the fuel surcharge.
Again, capitalism gets blamed for a cost structure government helped create.
Money is the deepest layer of all. When government spends more than it takes in, borrows endlessly, and depends on monetary policy to keep the whole machine moving, the dollar loses value over time. That loss of purchasing power is not dramatic in a single year. It is devastating over decades.
A little inflation sounds harmless when politicians and economists talk about it. Two percent here, three percent there. But inflation compounds. Given enough time, it changes civilization. A five-dollar hamburger becomes sixteen dollars. A five-thousand-dollar truck becomes fifty thousand. A fifty-thousand-dollar house becomes a million-dollar house in some markets.
People then ask why everything costs so much.
The answer is simple: the dollar buys less.
Private business did not create that cycle. Government did.
Businesses respond to the value of money. They do not create the value of money. A business owner charging more dollars for the same product may not be making more real profit at all. He may simply be trying to keep up with a currency that has been weakened beneath his feet.
This is where the attack on capitalism becomes morally backward. Capitalism creates goods and services. Government debases money. Then capitalism gets blamed when goods and services require more dollars.
A free market creates abundance. Bad policy makes abundance harder to afford.
Consider the smartphone. Many of capitalism’s loudest critics complain about capitalism on thousand-dollar phones using private-sector technology, private-sector platforms, private-sector networks, private-sector software, private-sector logistics, and private-sector innovation. They carry in their pockets a device more powerful than anything kings, presidents, or generals possessed for most of human history.
Capitalism made that possible.
And yet they say capitalism failed because rent is too high, tuition is impossible, health care is unaffordable, and wages do not stretch far enough.
They are right that life has become too expensive. They are wrong about why.
The real problem is not that capitalism cannot produce. The problem is that government has made the basics of life too expensive by manipulating, regulating, subsidizing, restricting, taxing, borrowing, and inflating.
That distinction matters because a wrong diagnosis produces a destructive cure.
If young people are taught that capitalism is the problem, they will demand more government control over the very sectors government has already distorted. Housing is too expensive, so they demand more government intervention. College is too expensive, so they demand more government money. Health care is too expensive, so they demand more government control. Wages are tight, so they demand more labor mandates. Energy is expensive, so they demand more centralized planning.
Then prices rise again, shortages grow worse, small businesses disappear, choices narrow, and the same voices say, “See? Capitalism failed.”
No. Capitalism was never allowed to work honestly.
That does not mean every business is virtuous. It does not mean every wealthy person earned wealth honorably. It does not mean corporations never behave badly. Some companies exploit government favors. Some lobby for regulations that crush their smaller competitors. Some use political influence to protect themselves from competition. Some enjoy subsidies, bailouts, tax preferences, and regulatory barriers that ordinary entrepreneurs could never access.
But that is not capitalism. That is cronyism.
There is a vast difference between a free market and a rigged market. In a free market, businesses win by serving customers better. In a rigged market, businesses win by influencing government. In a free market, profit is earned by creating value. In a rigged market, profit is protected by political power.
The answer to cronyism is not socialism. The answer is less favoritism, less manipulation, less central planning, and more honest competition.
The local business owner understands this better than most politicians. He lives in the real world. He knows he cannot mandate a profit into existence. He cannot raise wages beyond what the business can sustain. He cannot sell a product for less than it costs to produce. He cannot keep the doors open by pretending arithmetic is unfair.
Labor matters. Employees matter. Good workers are valuable. But wages have to fit inside the value customers are willing to pay for the product or service. Government can mandate a wage, but it cannot mandate customer demand. It can raise the cost of labor, but it cannot force customers to buy a sixteen-dollar hamburger.
When no one applies for a job at ten dollars an hour, the market is speaking. The employer must raise the wage, improve conditions, change the work, or go without help. That is a market signal. But when government imposes wages without knowing the margins, the customer base, the cost structure, or the survival point of the business, it is not wisdom. It is political theater with someone else’s money.
And when the business fails, the politician does not lose the house. The owner does.
That is another truth our culture forgets: ownership is risk. Employees sell labor for wages. Owners buy risk with their lives.
The owner signs the lease, borrows the money, buys the equipment, hires the staff, pays the insurance, manages the taxes, satisfies the regulators, and lies awake wondering whether payroll can be met. If the business succeeds, people complain that the owner made too much. If the business fails, the owner absorbs the loss.
Employees may lose a job. That is serious. But the owner may lose the business, the savings, the house, the credit, the reputation, and years of work.
A society that resents reward while depending on risk-takers is living off capital it no longer understands.
There has to be the possibility of great reward because there is the possibility of great loss. If the upside is capped while the downside remains unlimited, rational people stop taking risks. They stop opening restaurants. They stop building companies. They stop hiring workers. They stop signing notes. They stop betting on themselves.
Then everyone has less.
That is why defending capitalism is not about defending billionaires. It is about defending the right of ordinary people to create, build, risk, serve, profit, fail, recover, and try again.
It is about defending the system that allows a poor person to become middle class, a middle-class person to become wealthy, and an idea in a garage to become a company that changes the world.
The tragedy of our time is that too many people have been taught to envy the builder rather than become one. They have been taught to look at wealth and assume theft. They have been taught to see profit as exploitation rather than the oxygen that keeps a business alive.
They see capitalism’s storefront.
They do not see government’s machinery behind the wall.
So when prices rise, they blame the merchant. When rent rises, they blame the landlord. When wages disappoint, they blame the employer. When billionaires exist, they blame capitalism.
But the deeper causes are debt, inflation, regulation, taxation, artificial scarcity, distorted incentives, and government interference in the capitalist system.
Capitalism is not perfect because people are not perfect. But capitalism remains the greatest engine of abundance, innovation, opportunity, and upward mobility the world has ever known.
Government can provide order, courts, national defense, basic rules, and protection against fraud and force. But when government tries to manage everything, price everything, subsidize everything, regulate everything, and promise everything, it corrupts the signals that make markets work.
Capitalism is the engine.
Government is the road, the fuel, the speed limit, the toll booth, the traffic cop, and sometimes the guy throwing nails in the lane.
When the ride gets rough, people blame the engine.
They should look at the road.
No Loss for Words 
In Defense of Capitalism: Blaming the Engine for the Road Government Built
by Steve DanaYoung people today often say capitalism has failed them. They look at the cost of rent, groceries, gas, tuition, insurance, health care, and vehicles, and they conclude the system is broken. Then they look at Bill Gates, Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, Warren Buffett, Larry Ellison, and the rest of America’s billionaire class, and they decide they have found the villains.
It is an understandable reaction, but it is the wrong conclusion.
Capitalism did not make ordinary life unaffordable.
Government distorted capitalism until ordinary life became unaffordable, and then taught people to blame capitalism.
That is the point we need to recover.
Capitalism does not operate in a vacuum. It operates inside a framework created by government. Government controls the money supply. Government influences interest rates. Government taxes income, property, fuel, payroll, investment, business activity, and consumption. Government regulates housing, energy, transportation, labor, health care, education, banking, insurance, construction, and nearly every other sector of the economy.
Then private businesses are expected to function inside that framework, absorb those costs, comply with those rules, pay those taxes, survive those mandates, and still keep prices low enough that customers do not revolt.
When they cannot, capitalism gets blamed.
That is dishonest.
A restaurant owner does not set the price of a hamburger in a vacuum. He looks at beef, buns, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, fryer oil, paper goods, napkins, cleaning supplies, rent, utilities, insurance, wages, payroll taxes, workers’ compensation, credit-card fees, repairs, equipment, spoilage, licensing, bookkeeping, regulation, and debt service. He adds all those costs together, hopes customers will still walk through the door, and tries to make enough profit to survive.
If the hamburger that used to cost five dollars now costs sixteen, the lazy explanation is greed. The real explanation is cost.
And where do many of those costs come from? Inflation, regulation, labor mandates, taxes, energy policy, insurance mandates, compliance costs, permitting delays, and the steady destruction of the dollar’s purchasing power.
That is not Bill Gates’ fault. That is not Warren Buffett’s fault. That is not capitalism failing. That is government interference showing up on the menu board.
The same is true of housing. Builders did not forget how to build houses. Developers did not suddenly decide to make starter homes unaffordable. Government made land use more complicated, zoning more restrictive, permitting more expensive, environmental review more time-consuming, infrastructure fees more burdensome, and construction compliance more costly. Then people look around and wonder why young families cannot buy a house.
The answer is not capitalism. The answer is artificial scarcity created by government policy.
If government restricts where housing can be built, what kind of housing can be built, how dense it can be, how long approvals take, what fees must be paid, what materials must be used, and what conditions must be satisfied before a shovel hits the dirt, the result will be fewer homes and higher prices.
That is not a market failure. That is a government failure.
Energy is another example. Fuel is not just something we buy at the pump. Energy is embedded in everything. It is in farming, trucking, refrigeration, construction, manufacturing, shipping, warehousing, heating, cooling, and retail. Raise the cost of energy and you raise the cost of everything.
When government restricts supply, discourages investment, blocks infrastructure, mandates preferred technologies, or punishes certain fuels before alternatives are ready, the cost does not stay in the energy sector. It spreads through the entire economy.
The customer sees the price of groceries. The business owner sees the fuel surcharge.
Again, capitalism gets blamed for a cost structure government helped create.
Money is the deepest layer of all. When government spends more than it takes in, borrows endlessly, and depends on monetary policy to keep the whole machine moving, the dollar loses value over time. That loss of purchasing power is not dramatic in a single year. It is devastating over decades.
A little inflation sounds harmless when politicians and economists talk about it. Two percent here, three percent there. But inflation compounds. Given enough time, it changes civilization. A five-dollar hamburger becomes sixteen dollars. A five-thousand-dollar truck becomes fifty thousand. A fifty-thousand-dollar house becomes a million-dollar house in some markets.
People then ask why everything costs so much.
The answer is simple: the dollar buys less.
Private business did not create that cycle. Government did.
Businesses respond to the value of money. They do not create the value of money. A business owner charging more dollars for the same product may not be making more real profit at all. He may simply be trying to keep up with a currency that has been weakened beneath his feet.
This is where the attack on capitalism becomes morally backward. Capitalism creates goods and services. Government debases money. Then capitalism gets blamed when goods and services require more dollars.
A free market creates abundance. Bad policy makes abundance harder to afford.
Consider the smartphone. Many of capitalism’s loudest critics complain about capitalism on thousand-dollar phones using private-sector technology, private-sector platforms, private-sector networks, private-sector software, private-sector logistics, and private-sector innovation. They carry in their pockets a device more powerful than anything kings, presidents, or generals possessed for most of human history.
Capitalism made that possible.
And yet they say capitalism failed because rent is too high, tuition is impossible, health care is unaffordable, and wages do not stretch far enough.
They are right that life has become too expensive. They are wrong about why.
The real problem is not that capitalism cannot produce. The problem is that government has made the basics of life too expensive by manipulating, regulating, subsidizing, restricting, taxing, borrowing, and inflating.
That distinction matters because a wrong diagnosis produces a destructive cure.
If young people are taught that capitalism is the problem, they will demand more government control over the very sectors government has already distorted. Housing is too expensive, so they demand more government intervention. College is too expensive, so they demand more government money. Health care is too expensive, so they demand more government control. Wages are tight, so they demand more labor mandates. Energy is expensive, so they demand more centralized planning.
Then prices rise again, shortages grow worse, small businesses disappear, choices narrow, and the same voices say, “See? Capitalism failed.”
No. Capitalism was never allowed to work honestly.
That does not mean every business is virtuous. It does not mean every wealthy person earned wealth honorably. It does not mean corporations never behave badly. Some companies exploit government favors. Some lobby for regulations that crush their smaller competitors. Some use political influence to protect themselves from competition. Some enjoy subsidies, bailouts, tax preferences, and regulatory barriers that ordinary entrepreneurs could never access.
But that is not capitalism. That is cronyism.
There is a vast difference between a free market and a rigged market. In a free market, businesses win by serving customers better. In a rigged market, businesses win by influencing government. In a free market, profit is earned by creating value. In a rigged market, profit is protected by political power.
The answer to cronyism is not socialism. The answer is less favoritism, less manipulation, less central planning, and more honest competition.
The local business owner understands this better than most politicians. He lives in the real world. He knows he cannot mandate a profit into existence. He cannot raise wages beyond what the business can sustain. He cannot sell a product for less than it costs to produce. He cannot keep the doors open by pretending arithmetic is unfair.
Labor matters. Employees matter. Good workers are valuable. But wages have to fit inside the value customers are willing to pay for the product or service. Government can mandate a wage, but it cannot mandate customer demand. It can raise the cost of labor, but it cannot force customers to buy a sixteen-dollar hamburger.
When no one applies for a job at ten dollars an hour, the market is speaking. The employer must raise the wage, improve conditions, change the work, or go without help. That is a market signal. But when government imposes wages without knowing the margins, the customer base, the cost structure, or the survival point of the business, it is not wisdom. It is political theater with someone else’s money.
And when the business fails, the politician does not lose the house. The owner does.
That is another truth our culture forgets: ownership is risk. Employees sell labor for wages. Owners buy risk with their lives.
The owner signs the lease, borrows the money, buys the equipment, hires the staff, pays the insurance, manages the taxes, satisfies the regulators, and lies awake wondering whether payroll can be met. If the business succeeds, people complain that the owner made too much. If the business fails, the owner absorbs the loss.
Employees may lose a job. That is serious. But the owner may lose the business, the savings, the house, the credit, the reputation, and years of work.
A society that resents reward while depending on risk-takers is living off capital it no longer understands.
There has to be the possibility of great reward because there is the possibility of great loss. If the upside is capped while the downside remains unlimited, rational people stop taking risks. They stop opening restaurants. They stop building companies. They stop hiring workers. They stop signing notes. They stop betting on themselves.
Then everyone has less.
That is why defending capitalism is not about defending billionaires. It is about defending the right of ordinary people to create, build, risk, serve, profit, fail, recover, and try again.
It is about defending the system that allows a poor person to become middle class, a middle-class person to become wealthy, and an idea in a garage to become a company that changes the world.
The tragedy of our time is that too many people have been taught to envy the builder rather than become one. They have been taught to look at wealth and assume theft. They have been taught to see profit as exploitation rather than the oxygen that keeps a business alive.
They see capitalism’s storefront.
They do not see government’s machinery behind the wall.
So when prices rise, they blame the merchant. When rent rises, they blame the landlord. When wages disappoint, they blame the employer. When billionaires exist, they blame capitalism.
But the deeper causes are debt, inflation, regulation, taxation, artificial scarcity, distorted incentives, and government interference in the capitalist system.
Capitalism is not perfect because people are not perfect. But capitalism remains the greatest engine of abundance, innovation, opportunity, and upward mobility the world has ever known.
Government can provide order, courts, national defense, basic rules, and protection against fraud and force. But when government tries to manage everything, price everything, subsidize everything, regulate everything, and promise everything, it corrupts the signals that make markets work.
Capitalism is the engine.
Government is the road, the fuel, the speed limit, the toll booth, the traffic cop, and sometimes the guy throwing nails in the lane.
When the ride gets rough, people blame the engine.
They should look at the road.
Posted in Affordable Housing, Economic Development, Political commentary, Regulatory Reform | Leave a Comment »